I went to a barbecue yesterday that turned into a mini-reunion with some friends from high school. While there, I realized that I hadn't seen or even exchanged a single kilobyte of communication with some of them for years. Naturally, I am closer with some than with others, but I would consider them all to be my friends. Despite a lack of purposeful communication with some of these folks, thanks to the magic/voyeurism/intrusion (depending on your p.o.v.) of facebook, I had at least some idea of what they had been up to since were last in touch. Now it's great that through social networking sites (SNSs) like facebook, myspace, and twitter, we can keep tabs on our friends, but we are doing so, largely without meaningful/purposeful communication. It struck me that by allowing us to passively consume constant updates on what our friends are up to, without us actively communicating with them, SNSs give us the illusion of staying in touch.
Now let's not get it twisted, SNSs are amazing tools that allow us to organize, manage and rediscover relationships (for better or worse) in a way that our parents' address books and rolodexes never could. I'm just wondering where these tools are taking us...
We are the generation that grew up with AIM. We witnessed electronic communications progress from beepers and Zach Morris phones, to cell phones and all encompassing smart phones like iPhones and Blackberrys. With the growth of the internet and the recent explosion of SNSs, we have attained unparalleled access to a variety of electronic communication mediums. We are more reachable as individuals than at any other time in history, so why are we doing less meaningful communication?
We are now digital and wireless, no longer analog and wired. Wireless means remote and mobile, whereas, Wired inherently means close and fixed. Is this an analogy for where we are headed relationally? Remote + mobile relationships versus close + fixed relationship? We have so many ways to communicate with one another, it seems like our communication itself has become more distant and diluted (read, superficial). SNSs do offer us windows into the lives of our friends -- but let us not forget that when you are at a window, you are on the outside looking in. You catch glimpses of your friends' lives as they come in and out of view. Windows also represent a tangible barrier -- in this case the LCD screens that you and I stare at everyday to learn what our friends are up to. Instead of being active participants, are we being lulled into a form of passive electronic friend surveillance? If that's the case, then we might as well implant microchips into all of our friends that feed us constant live updates of their exact geographic location, with text, photos, and streaming video, letting us know what they are doing -- how about we call it, "iTrack"?
I want to go back to the days where I had memorized the phone numbers of my close friends and I used to call them and make arrangements to see them on a regular basis. I wanna bring back play-dates, in a grown way of course, and place an emphasis on face time and phone time with my network, rather than time spent in cyberspace viewing status updates and photos. With the passing of time, "write me," became "call me." To that, we've recently added "email me," "text me," and even, "skype me." Will the new phrases be "follow my twitter feed" or "add me to your facebook newsfeed?"
Adults-in-Training, what do you think about the way we communicate these days and what it's doing to the depth of our relationships? Have SNSs brought us closer together -- or do we just appear to be so, thanks to the illusion of staying in touch?
3 comments:
I think it's all one big illusion. Since moving away from all my college friends, when I graduated from college and even more so when I moved to NYC, I have had to resort to more unfavorable forms of communication to stay "in touch" somewhat rather than risk losing the friendship as I needed it to be. I've had to compromise and I don't like it. I like face time over the phone, but I'm not where they are (can't help that). So, I would rather talk on the phone than have conversations through texting or keeping tabs on facebook. But alas, I've had to resort to such things. Did I mention I don't like it? Also, as I meet new people they are already at the level that I had to unwillingly compromise to get to and it's all just annoying and lacking in all things good (I'm being dramatic but I think you get my point).
I totally get your point. Social networks supposedly have 6 degrees of separation, it now seems we are verging on 6 degrees of communication (some more unfavorable than others as you point out) based on where we are and where the majority of our friends are geographically. Proxmity definitely determines how we communicate, but it's sad that we still use facebook to track people who live in the same city! Face times is best, followed by phone time, and all other forms come after...
Are we forced to compromise or do we choose to?
A friend of mine makes a list of people he needs to call and goes through it on the weekend once a month...I think i'm going to implement that...
As a Facebook addict, I think I would be remiss to say that there isn't value to online social networking sites. It's definitely a good tool to find people that you've lost touch with, or to give your friends a basic idea of what you're up to. However, as a tool for *building* a friendship, I don't think it can replace a good phone call or an old-fashioned face to face. I'm a firm believer in "reach out and touch someone" (wow, I am going old school here -Nii, you might be too young to remember that phrase - j/k!) But I think though technology has changed, humanity has not. We still need that human contact - to hear someone's voice, to see their smile, to hug them, etc, and those are things that status updates and Tweets can never replace.
By the way... one time, I asked a friend (whom I hadn't spoken with in a few months) how a particular situation was going in her life, and she literally told me, "Read my blog." Ok... you couldn't spend the 5 minutes and have a conversation with me about it? Case in point...
Post a Comment